Wayne County Homes under $400,000

Wayne County Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Wayne County, New York – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Finger Lakes region. Known for its picturesque landscapes, charming small towns, and vibrant community spirit, Wayne County offers a perfect blend of rural tranquility and modern convenience. With its lush vineyards, serene lakes, and scenic parks, it’s a haven for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike.

One of the most appealing aspects of Wayne County is the affordability of its housing market. If you’re searching for a home under $400,000, you’ll find an array of delightful options that cater to various lifestyles and preferences. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, a growing family, or looking to downsize, Wayne County has something for everyone.

Imagine waking up in a cozy single-family home surrounded by stunning views of rolling hills, or perhaps a charming bungalow just a stone's throw from the beautiful shores of Lake Ontario. With properties featuring spacious yards, modern amenities, and proximity to local schools and shopping, you can enjoy a fulfilling lifestyle without breaking the bank.

In addition to affordable homes, Wayne County boasts a rich cultural tapestry, with local festivals, farmers' markets, and community events that bring residents together. The county’s strong sense of community and friendly atmosphere make it an ideal place to call home.

Explore the possibilities in Wayne County, where your dream home awaits at an unbeatable price. Start your journey today and discover the charm and affordability that this enchanting region has to offer!

Newest Wayne County Homes under $400,000

6878 Tuckahoe Road, Williamson
$249,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1725007 MLS
Welcome to 6878 Tuckahoe Road! This beautiful 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath raised ranch sits on a spacious 0.49-acre lot in the heart of Williamson, NY! Featuring a 1-car attached garage, a large bonus room and a versatile garden level offering potential for an in-law suite or additional living space, this home provides flexibility for a variety of needs! A beautiful, enclosed rear porch offers stunning views of the surrounding countryside, providing the perfect place to relax and take in the scenic landscape! Enjoy the charm of country living surrounded by picturesque apple orchards, farms, scenic landscapes and the rich agricultural heritage that makes this community so special. Known as "The Core of Apple Country," Williamson offers a wonderful blend of small-town charm, history and outdoor recreation. Explore nearby Williamson Town Park, the beautiful Lake Ontario shoreline, B. Forman Park and historic Pultneyville, with its waterfront views, local attractions and historic architecture. Enjoy seasonal farm markets, fresh local produce and Williamson's annual Apple Blossom Festival! Convenient access to Routes 104 and 21 makes commuting to Rochester and surrounding Wayne County communities easy. Experience the beauty, character and lifestyle of one of Wayne County's most charming communities. Your opportunity to call Williamson home awaits! Delayed negotiations on file. All offers due Tuesday, November 3, 2026, at 5:00 PM. OPEN HOUSE SATURDAY 10/31/26- 1:30PM-3:30PM.

6878 Tuckahoe Road, Williamson
3885 W Walworth Road, Walworth
$375,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1724726 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully maintained 1890 farmhouse on over 3 acres in Walworth! Just 1 mile to the Monroe County line, and 6 minutes to Penfield, this property offers more than 2,000 square feet of character-filled living and five bedrooms, including two on the first floor! Timeless charm meets thoughtful updates throughout. A covered front porch leads into a spacious foyer with rich wood trim and refinished hardwood floors that flow through the main level. Some fresh wallpaper, new ceilings, and new trim in areas of the home add a nice polished look, and there is even hardwood beneath the carpets! The living room is anchored by a wood stove, perfect for cozy fall and winter evenings. French doors open to the formal dining room, where wainscoting and a wall of windows frame views of the open land. The updated eat-in kitchen features Oak wood cabinetry, Quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a gas range. The first floor includes two bedrooms and a full bath, while three more bedrooms and an updated second full bath are upstairs, ideal for guests, a home office, or multi-generational living. Outside, you’ll appreciate the new gutters with new soffits and aluminum fascia, painted windows, blacktop driveway with turnaround, and the open porch for enjoying the view. The 2.5-car attached garage, added in 2012, connects by breezeway to the full walkout basement, with redone basement stairs. This property has plenty of room to garden, gather, and grow. Showings begin Wednesday, 10/28 @9AM. Delayed Negotiations until Tuesday, 11/2/26 @10AM.

3885 W Walworth Road, Walworth
11961 Butler Street, Butler
$75,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1724728 MLS
Tucked right in the Village of Wolcott, this 3-bedroom home is packed with potential and ready for your personal touch! Featuring convenient first-floor living with a full bath, laundry, and space for a main-level bedroom. The bright living room and formal dining room offer plenty of room to gather, work, or play. Step outside to a private, fully fenced backyard patio—ideal for entertaining or relaxing in your own oasis. Some major functional upgrades have already been done, including a newer water heater, and furnace. A fantastic starter home or flip project! Delayed negotiation until 11/3/26 at 12pm.

11961 Butler Street, Butler
736 N Main Street, Arcadia
$124,900
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ R1725023 MLS
According to the Historical Society, this brick home was owned by only 4 families, including the current owner. The abstract goes back to 1899, but the home was built in 1860 by Theodore Hunt, who owned it until he deeded it over to his daughter in 1901. His daughter owned it until August of 1948 when it was sold to the Benzie family, and then it was sold in 1974 to Mr. Russell; it was then sold in 1975 to the current owner. The historical records indicate that the Benzie family converted the single family residence into a multi-family home which now consists of 4 apartments. One large apartment is on the first floor, 2 small apartments are on the second floor, and another apartment is in the rear of the house. This is an Estate and is being sold "as is." The home needs a significant amount of work and must be shown during the day as the electric has been shut off.

736 N Main Street, Arcadia
2892 Ontario Center Road, Macedon
$269,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1725118 MLS
Country living in a well maintained home! Comfortable floor plan with a sunny living room with large poicture window and wood-burning fireplace, a formal dining room, and a spacious eat-in kitchen. You will enjoy the warmer months in the three season room overlooking a private backyard backing to woods; enjoy the sunrise with your morning coffee. Three large bedrooms upstairs. Both baths recently remodeled. All major updates have been done here...vinyl siding, windows, main roof. Furnace and water heater new in 2024. New flooring in kitchen, baths and bedrooms. Brand new rec room in walkout basement, featuring a gas stove and expoxy floor for multipurpose use: home theater, play area, gym, or additional bedroom. Two car garage with an electric car charger and triple-wide driveway (new in 2024) and a third bay off to the side for lawn mower, toys, storage or workshop. Close to Gananda, and a short drive to Penfield. No delayed negotiations...get here fast! OPEN HOUSE Saturday 12-2.

2892 Ontario Center Road, Macedon
5121 Ridge Rd, Williamson
$179,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1724902 MLS
Welcome to this beautiful two-story brick and stone home, bursting with timeless character and charm! Offering 4 spacious bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms, this home combines classic appeal with plenty of room to make it your own. Enjoy a generously sized yard, perfect for outdoor entertaining, gardening, or simply relaxing. Conveniently located near Route 104, with easy access to local restaurants, shopping, and everyday amenities. With its distinctive brick and stone exterior, inviting atmosphere, and unique architectural character, this home offers a wonderful opportunity to own a property full of personality and potential. Pergola is staying, fireplaces are as is. Open house on Saturday October 31st from 11AM to 1230PM with delayed negotiations until Tuesday November 3rd at 3pm.

5121 Ridge Rd, Williamson
4120 Dix Street, Rose
$169,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1724448 MLS
Plenty of space in this 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home located on half an acre in a quiet hamlet with semi-private backyard backing up to woods. Natural woodwork, a floating staircase and hardwood floors add a sense of history and warmth. There are a screened porch, mudroom and full bath at the back of the house making it convenient for coming in from outdoor activities. There is a room off the living room for an office, playroom or convert to a first floor bedroom. You have a choice of placing the laundry room on the first and/or second floor. Improvements include: New metal roof & septic system 2012, 200 amp panel box, water heater & pex plumbing 2024. Insulation and new wiring 2011. Dining room walls, largest bedroom ceiling & kitchen floor 2026. New Shed 2016. All appliances & furnishings included. Great bones and all the updates provide you a perfect canvas for bringing out the glory of this comfortable home.

4120 Dix Street, Rose
6659 South Street, Wolcott
$209,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1724694 MLS
Come enjoy the beauty of what this home has to offer. Totally renovated with owner's care shining through. This 4-bedroom 2 full bath home has so much to offer hardwood floors, wood floors, new wall to wall to carpet, new kitchen with brand-new stainless-steel appliances. large new sink, New Sheet rock new windows, new metal roof, 1 car garage redone. big additional shed for more storage, large yard, walk to town or the rec center, all ready for you to move right in. No Showings until Oct 24 2026 at noon

6659 South Street, Wolcott
7147 Maxwell Road, Sodus
$389,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1724374 MLS
Discover the charm of country living with this distinctive cobblestone farmhouse set on 10.35 scenic acres along a peaceful rural country road, conveniently located near the Lake Ontario and Sodus Point resort area. Offering a blend of historic character, modern updates, and endless possibilities, this inviting home features 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and a spacious updated kitchen with a center island—perfect for cooking, gathering, and entertaining. A welcoming mudroom with built-in storage provides a practical entry, while the spacious family room offers plenty of room to relax. The property also features two garages, a large barn, and established apple orchards, with horses permitted for those seeking a country lifestyle. Enjoy the outdoors from the deck or covered porch, with 10.35 acres to explore and enjoy. The flexible layout offers potential for an in-law apartment or additional living space. Large 52'x105' pole barn with 14' ceilings, 40' x30' partially headed shop, and newer 28'x32' garage! With a new septic system and a desirable location near the area's lakeside attractions, this unique property offers a wonderful opportunity to enjoy country living with room to roam! Delayed Negotiations, offers due November 4th at 12:00pm.

7147 Maxwell Road, Sodus
5630 Lincoln Road, Ontario
$290,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1724378 MLS
**FRESHLY UPDATED, SINGLE-LEVEL LIVING & GARAGE SPACE GALORE!** This 3-bedroom ranch packs a punch with a beautifully refreshed interior, an oversized 0.64-acre lot & something you don't find every day... **BOTH AN ATTACHED GARAGE AND A 24' x 30' DETACHED GARAGE WITH ELECTRIC!** **FRESH, BRIGHT & BEAUTIFULLY REFRESHED!** Updated flooring, fresh neutral paint, crisp white trim & modern finishes throughout! **SPACIOUS LIVING ROOM!** Large picture window fills the space with natural light! **UPDATED KITCHEN!** White cabinetry, gorgeous quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, recessed lighting & additional cabinetry for extra storage and workspace! **DINING AREA!** Conveniently located just off the kitchen. **THREE BEDROOMS & AN UPDATED FULL BATH!** Fresh finishes throughout, including a modern vanity & tiled tub/shower surround. **FULL BASEMENT!** Bright, open & unfinished with laundry, workshop space & plenty of storage! **ROOM TO SPREAD OUT!** An expansive backyard with mature trees, a beautiful wooded backdrop & plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors! **AND THE GARAGES?!** An attached garage PLUS an impressive 720 sq. ft. detached garage with electric... perfect for vehicles, hobbies, a workshop or all the extras! DELAYED NEGOTIATIONS THROUGH THURSDAY 10/29 @ 12PM

5630 Lincoln Road, Ontario
476 Ontario Drive, Ontario
$289,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1723767 MLS
What if lake views didn’t have to come with a lakefront price tag? This fully updated ranch in the Town of Ontario sits just across the street from Lake Ontario, and you can see the water right from your living room window. This home has been refreshed from top to bottom. The brand new kitchen is the showstopper: quartz countertops, white subway tile backsplash, warm wood cabinetry with gold hardware, recessed lighting, and all new stainless steel appliances. You’ll love the cabinet and counter space, plus a side door that steps right out to the new deck. The living room is bright and welcoming, with a big picture window framing the lake view and a classic brick fireplace for gathering on chilly evenings. New flooring runs throughout the entire house, and fresh neutral paint gives you a clean slate to make it your own. Three bedrooms and an updated bathroom with a new vanity and all new fixtures complete the main floor. Downstairs, the partially finished basement offers flexible space for a rec room, home gym, or office, along with plenty of storage. The big-ticket items are already done: new roof in 2020 (shed included), new furnace in 2024, and new water heater in 2026. Outside, enjoy the new front porch, fresh landscaping, a spacious backyard, and a shed for your outdoor gear. Picture summer mornings with coffee on the porch, breezy walks along the lakeshore, and weekends soaking up everything Wayne County has to offer. Lake access is just across the street, so the water becomes part of your everyday life without the lakefront upkeep or price. One-floor living, a move-in ready interior, and lake views at this price point don’t come along often. No delayed negotiations- don't miss this one!

476 Ontario Drive, Ontario
1421 Sunrise Drive, Macedon
$269,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1724197 MLS
Welcome to this BEAUTIFULLY UPDATED Raised Ranch, nestled on a peaceful neighborhood corner lot in the sought-after Gananda community of Walworth! Offering 1,372 sq. ft. of comfortable, functional living space designed for both daily relaxation and effortless entertaining. Step inside to a bright and airy main level featuring a warm, open-concept living and dining layout complete with classic hardwood-style flooring, and large thermal windows that fill the home with natural light. The well-appointed kitchen offers ample counter space, including a breakfast bar featuring a wood crafted countertop. pantry, living dining room combo and direct sliding glass door access to your private outdoor deck—perfect for morning coffee or summertime barbecues! Down the hall is a FULL BATH, three spacious bedrooms (1 currently serves as an office). Head to the lower level for more finished space (not included in the square footage)! Including a large room (currently used as MAIN SUITE) provides a perfect spot for family/rec room with access to the attached garage. Another FULL BATH with walk-in shower. Laundry room with storage. A bonus room which can be another bedroom. Finally, the FULLY FENCED back yard provides safety and privacy... and a shed to store maintenance equipment. There is nothing to do except move in! Delayed negotiations begin Wednesday November 4 at 1pm. Please give 24 hours to respond.

1421 Sunrise Drive, Macedon
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!