Wheatland Homes for Sale

Wheatland Homes for Sale

Welcome to Wheatland, New York—a charming town nestled in the heart of Monroe County, where rural tranquility meets modern convenience. With its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Wheatland is the perfect place to call home for families, professionals, and retirees alike.

Wheatland boasts an array of outdoor activities, thanks to its lush parks and scenic trails that invite residents to explore the beauty of nature. Whether you’re hiking through the stunning trails of the nearby Genesee Valley Park or enjoying a leisurely afternoon at one of the local parks, adventure is always just around the corner. The town also prides itself on its strong sense of community, hosting various events throughout the year that bring neighbors together and foster lasting friendships.

As you consider making Wheatland your home, you’ll find a diverse selection of homes for sale. From charming single-family residences with spacious yards to modern townhomes that offer low-maintenance living, there’s something to suit every lifestyle and budget. Many of these homes feature beautiful architectural details, updated amenities, and proximity to local schools, shops, and dining options.

With its ideal blend of rural charm and urban accessibility, Wheatland is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. Explore the current listings and find your dream home in this welcoming community today! Whether you’re a first-time buyer or looking to settle down, Wheatland offers a unique blend of comfort and opportunity. Come and experience the warmth and charm of Wheatland, NY!

Newest Wheatland Homes for Sale

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ R1710824 MLS

Fall in love! This is your chance to own a historic mansion; lovingly restored by the owner engineer and former President of the Wheatland Historic Association. It's in the details! Every detail inside and out was planned to provide and meet modern codes and conveniences while preserving this home's stunning old-world charm. The gorgeous kitchen with center island hosts a functioning wood-burning stove, right alongside the modern stove and overlooks the morning room. The well-balanced living space includes a family room, formal dining room, living room, and so much more. There are 2 bedrooms with complete ensuite, that would be great for owner's quarters; one is on the main level. First floor laundry room and full bath as added conveniences on the maim level. Charming 1/2 bath and a private office space round out the first floor living space. Two stairways lead to the 2nd floor; with a wide hallway, wall to wall carpeting, storage areas. Gaze out and take in the breathtaking views of the yard and gardens; filled with mature landscaping, fruit shrubs and fruit trees, a koi pond, and covered porch/deck areas. Want more space and storage? Step into the 3- car attached garage, or the detached 3 car barn; complete with solar panels. More details; the roof is approximately 9 years old, the hot water tank was installed in 2024, the septic system was replaced in 2016, windows replaced in all but one room, the solar panel system was installed in approximately 2018. Owner provided updated square footage, to 3794 This home is solid and ready for you to move right in. Delayed negotiations, with offers due 9/4/2026 at 1:00 pm.

868 Winslow Road, Wheatland

10 Beds ⋅ 12 Baths ⋅ R1710426 MLS

Welcome to 948 George St, a beautifully maintained creekside residence in the heart of the Genesee Valley, where Spring Creek flows gently through your own backyard. Known as the Genesee Country Inn, this exceptional property offers the rare chance to own a spacious, character-filled home with the built-in option of a turnkey income stream. Imagine mornings with coffee overlooking the creek, watching deer and wildlife wander the grounds, and evenings on the porch listening to the water — all just minutes from Western New York's charm and countryside. The home's inviting layout, multiple comfortable guest accommodations, and welcoming common spaces make it equally suited to large-family living, multigenerational households, or hosting friends and visitors in style. For those intrigued by the idea of supplemental income without a full commercial commitment, the property's established bed & breakfast history means the infrastructure is already in place — private guest suites, a warm gathering room, and a reputation for hospitality already built by the current owners. Continue hosting regularly, rent rooms seasonally, or simply enjoy the home as a private retreat — the choice is yours. The property is currently an operating bed & breakfast, giving a buyer the freedom to convert it fully to a private residence right away or ease into that transition over time. This property is a once in a lifetime opportunity. Schedule your showing today.

948 George Street, Wheatland

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1709461 MLS

WELCOME TO 5 DEPOT PLACE IN MUMFORD! TUCKED BACK OFF THE ROAD AND SURROUNDED BY WOODS AND OPEN FARM FIELDS, THIS PROPERTY OFFERS A PEACEFUL, PRIVATE SETTING WITH PLENTY OF OPPORTUNITIES TO ENJOY THE ABUNDANT LOCAL WILDLIFE RIGHT OUTSIDE YOUR DOOR. SITUATED ON APPROXIMATELY 1.5 ACRES WITH AN ADDITIONAL 0.25-ACRE PARCEL INCLUDED, THERE’S PLENTY OF ROOM TO MAKE THIS PROPERTY YOUR OWN. THE HOME IS IN NEED OF RENOVATIONS, MAKING IT A GREAT OPPORTUNITY FOR AN INVESTOR, CONTRACTOR, OR BUYER LOOKING TO BRING THEIR VISION TO LIFE. ENJOY THE QUIET COUNTRY SURROUNDINGS WHILE STILL BEING JUST MINUTES FROM THE VILLAGE OF CALEDONIA AND NEARBY CONVENIENCES. WITH PRIVACY, ACREAGE, WILDLIFE, AND TONS OF POTENTIAL, THIS IS YOUR CHANCE TO TRANSFORM A TUCKED-AWAY PROPERTY INTO SOMETHING SPECIAL. PROPERTY IS BEING SOLD AS-IS, WHERE-IS.

5 Depot Place, Wheatland

Start Your Search

Eric Geoca

Growing up in a real estate family, I developed a love for real estate from a young age. Geoca Homes Realty was started, by my parents, in 1977. I first earned my real estate license at the age of 18. I received my degree in Electrical Engineering from Bucknell University and received a Master’s degree from Pace University in Business Administration with a specialty in Finance. While working in the corporate world for 17 years, I was awarded several patents relating to the fields of navigation, guidance and control as well as connection technologies. I returned to full time real estate in 2007, when I started building homes. In 2010, I earned my broker’s license and have been the managing broker for Geoca Homes Realty for the last 16 years. As a home builder who worked in the trades during college, I have a true understanding of homes and how they are constructed. I have built over 100 custom homes, as well as rehabbed historic homes. During our 49-year history, we have successfully served clients throughout the Rochester area and the Finger Lakes Region.

Learn More

Tara Morgan

With the heart of an educator and the drive of an entrepreneur, Tara Morgan entered the real estate profession subsequent to her many years as a high school English teacher and as an adjunct professor of writing/research methodologies. As a dedicated teacher, she brought literature and writing to life—often using nature and out-of-classroom settings as springboards for authentic learning. Shortly after the start of her real estate career, Tara became a multi-million-dollar producer and a recipient of several sales and client-service awards. Known for her professionalism, positive attitude, and strong work ethic, Tara rapidly built a thriving business with her client-centered approach. She is steadfast in her belief that agents must add real value to any real estate transaction in which they are involved, using knowledge, integrity, compassion, and patience. She is a proud mother of two incredible young ladies. Architecture, photography, and history are some of her favorite diversions. Tara holds a Master of Science in Childhood Education and a Bachelor of Arts in Journalism/Communications. She is a New York State Licensed Real Estate Salesperson and an SRES (Seniors Real Estate Specialist-NAR Designation).

Learn More

Jeff Griggs

As a real estate agent with Geoca Homes, Jeff Griggs believes clients should feel informed, supported, and never rushed when purchasing or selling a home. After a career as a firefighter, Jeff brings a calm, steady approach built on trust, communication, and service. Family is at the center of everything Jeff does and he understands how important a home is to building stability and lasting memories. He takes pride in guiding his clients every step of the way, with care and attention to detail.

Learn More

Lynne Tempest

Lynne Tempest grew up in a family-owned real estate and home building business, seeing firsthand what goes into helping people buy, sell, and build homes. She began her career at an advertising agency in Rochester, NY, before moving to New Jersey to work for the nation’s largest consumer wireless carrier where she launched Verizon’s "Can you hear me now?" campaign, successfully shifting consumer focus from price to premium service. She was responsible for go-to-market strategy, project management, and cross-functional leadership to build advertising, events, and social media content that delivered measurable results. Lynne's professional experience honed exceptional marketing, organization, negotiation, and problem-solving skills that she now applies to assist clients with their real estate goals.

Learn More