Seneca Homes for Sale

Seneca Homes for Sale

Welcome to Seneca, New York, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Ontario County. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Seneca offers a unique blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. With its stunning views of the Finger Lakes and proximity to outdoor recreational activities, residents enjoy a lifestyle that celebrates both nature and community spirit.

Seneca boasts a rich history intertwined with the natural beauty of the region. As you stroll through the quaint streets, you’ll find a variety of local shops, eateries, and parks that foster a strong sense of belonging. The area is perfect for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life.

For those looking to make Seneca their home, there are a variety of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. From cozy single-family homes with charming front porches to modern residences with spacious backyards, Seneca's real estate market has something for everyone. Many properties boast stunning views of the surrounding hills and lakes, making every day feel like a vacation.

Seneca is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. With excellent schools, a strong sense of community, and an abundance of outdoor activities, it’s no wonder that so many are drawn to this beautiful area. Explore the homes for sale in Seneca today, and discover the perfect backdrop for your next chapter!

Newest Seneca Homes for Sale

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1708553 MLS

Historic 1864 farmhouse on 8 private acres in the Finger Lakes. Move-in ready with about 2,450 sq. ft. in the main home plus 980 sq. ft. of additional finished/usable space. 3 bedrooms, 2½ baths, and 10-foot ceilings. Beautifully maintained and smoke-free, with a freshly painted porch, river-rock stone facing, and a mix of hardwood, luxury vinyl plank, and original floors. Features a beautiful kitchen, a large entertainment/family room, a spacious primary bath with dual-sink vanity and walk-in tile shower, dedicated laundry, and a flexible craft/office room. The land is the showpiece: established gardens, mature hydrangeas, hostas and clematis, fruit trees (four apple varieties, pear, cherry, elderberry), Concord grape vines, a covered patio, paved driveway, and a pond stocked with koi, goldfish, and shubunkin. Two barns, two lean-tos, and a detached 2-car garage. One barn has electric fencing around 1½+ acres, a 200-amp panel, loft storage, and tin roofing on the garage, one barn, and both lean-tos. 100-amp service to the garage. Hand-laid brick flooring, a ~6-ft basement. Geneva, Canandaigua, and Penn Yan are each under 15 minutes; Rochester about 50 minutes; three Finger Lakes and Bristol Mountain about15 minutes. Ideal as a historic home, hobby farm, animal property, or quiet country retreat. Do not wait! Delayed showings until 08/28/2026 and delayed negotiations 09/04/2026 @ 3pm. Allow 24 hours to review offers. Open house Sat. Aug. 29th 4-6 pm.

4960 Little Church Road, Seneca

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ R1709532 MLS

Stunning Custom -Built Country Ranch tucked off the road. Inviting front porch overlooking a peaceful setting. Open floor plan greets you with a warm living room and gas fireplace. Heated tile floors! The ultimate cooks' kitchen with large island, newer appliances, cabinets galore and quartz countertops. Primary ensuite features walk in closet, spacious tiled shower and soaking tub. 1st floor laundry for convenience. Two more bedrooms, one is another ensuite. Lower level is mostly finished with family room with gas fireplace, bar area, craft room and yet another ensuite. After a long day, unwind in the indoor pool! Stroll outside to the beautiful, landscaped yard complete with built in kitchen, black stone, and grills for entertaining. Whether it's a hobby or work related, an additional bonus is the five year old 60x120 workshop barn. Attached 14x10 shed for the outdoor lawn mower or tractor. This property is truly a must see to appreciate. Conveniently located to Canandaigua, Geneva, Penn Yan and all that the Finger Lakes have to offer. Additional, adjacent 1.8 acre parcel is available for sale. Delayed negotiations 9/9 at 1:00.

3900 Flint Road, Seneca

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1683726 MLS

Welcome to 1399 Lake to Lake Rd! Beautifully updated 1800’s farmhouse situated on a peaceful, private lot with mature landscaping. Ideal for entertaining with a spacious living room featuring vaulted ceilings and gas fireplace, plus a rear parlor perfect for a bar, game room, or pool table. Backyard oasis includes a patio, inground pool, and plenty of space for a future hot tub. All 4 bedrooms are located on the second floor. Spacious primary suite offers a separate dressing room with custom shoe shelving, large walk-in closet, and ensuite bath with double sink vanity. Large 2-car garage and additional outbuilding provide ample storage and workspace. A rare combination of historic charm, modern updates, and private outdoor living!

1399 Lake To Lake Road, Seneca

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1682785 MLS

So Much Potential! This developed property offers a rare opportunity to rebuild or create your dream home. The former two-story residence (3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, full basement) sustained fire damage, but many components—including windows and other salvageable parts—remain. The level acreage features a pond, a shop/garage, and essential utilities already in place: public water, septic, and electric. Appliances (furnace, hot water heater) are included in as-is condition. Conveniently located halfway between Canandaigua and Geneva in the Marcus Whitman School District, this property combines rural tranquility with easy access to nearby amenities. Bring your vision and make this property shine! Do not walk the property without an appointment.

3515 Seneca Castle Road, Seneca

Start Your Search

Eric Geoca

Growing up in a real estate family, I developed a love for real estate from a young age. Geoca Homes Realty was started, by my parents, in 1977. I first earned my real estate license at the age of 18. I received my degree in Electrical Engineering from Bucknell University and received a Master’s degree from Pace University in Business Administration with a specialty in Finance. While working in the corporate world for 17 years, I was awarded several patents relating to the fields of navigation, guidance and control as well as connection technologies. I returned to full time real estate in 2007, when I started building homes. In 2010, I earned my broker’s license and have been the managing broker for Geoca Homes Realty for the last 16 years. As a home builder who worked in the trades during college, I have a true understanding of homes and how they are constructed. I have built over 100 custom homes, as well as rehabbed historic homes. During our 49-year history, we have successfully served clients throughout the Rochester area and the Finger Lakes Region.

Learn More

Tara Morgan

With the heart of an educator and the drive of an entrepreneur, Tara Morgan entered the real estate profession subsequent to her many years as a high school English teacher and as an adjunct professor of writing/research methodologies. As a dedicated teacher, she brought literature and writing to life—often using nature and out-of-classroom settings as springboards for authentic learning. Shortly after the start of her real estate career, Tara became a multi-million-dollar producer and a recipient of several sales and client-service awards. Known for her professionalism, positive attitude, and strong work ethic, Tara rapidly built a thriving business with her client-centered approach. She is steadfast in her belief that agents must add real value to any real estate transaction in which they are involved, using knowledge, integrity, compassion, and patience. She is a proud mother of two incredible young ladies. Architecture, photography, and history are some of her favorite diversions. Tara holds a Master of Science in Childhood Education and a Bachelor of Arts in Journalism/Communications. She is a New York State Licensed Real Estate Salesperson and an SRES (Seniors Real Estate Specialist-NAR Designation).

Learn More

Jeff Griggs

As a real estate agent with Geoca Homes, Jeff Griggs believes clients should feel informed, supported, and never rushed when purchasing or selling a home. After a career as a firefighter, Jeff brings a calm, steady approach built on trust, communication, and service. Family is at the center of everything Jeff does and he understands how important a home is to building stability and lasting memories. He takes pride in guiding his clients every step of the way, with care and attention to detail.

Learn More

Lynne Tempest

Lynne Tempest grew up in a family-owned real estate and home building business, seeing firsthand what goes into helping people buy, sell, and build homes. She began her career at an advertising agency in Rochester, NY, before moving to New Jersey to work for the nation’s largest consumer wireless carrier where she launched Verizon’s "Can you hear me now?" campaign, successfully shifting consumer focus from price to premium service. She was responsible for go-to-market strategy, project management, and cross-functional leadership to build advertising, events, and social media content that delivered measurable results. Lynne's professional experience honed exceptional marketing, organization, negotiation, and problem-solving skills that she now applies to assist clients with their real estate goals.

Learn More