Palmyra Homes for Sale

Palmyra Homes for Sale

Welcome to Palmyra, New York—a charming village nestled in the heart of Wayne County, where history meets modern living. Known for its rich heritage, Palmyra is often celebrated as the birthplace of the Latter Day Saint movement and boasts a vibrant community spirit. With its picturesque landscapes, friendly neighborhoods, and a strong sense of community, Palmyra offers a serene lifestyle while being conveniently located near larger cities.

Palmyra is surrounded by stunning natural beauty, including the scenic Erie Canal, which serves as a perfect backdrop for outdoor enthusiasts. Residents enjoy a plethora of recreational activities, from hiking and biking to boating and fishing. The village also features a variety of local shops, delightful eateries, and annual festivals that bring the community together, making it a wonderful place to call home.

If you’re considering making Palmyra your home, you’ll be pleased to know that there are a variety of homes for sale that cater to different tastes and needs. From charming historic homes that exude character to modern residences equipped with the latest amenities, Palmyra’s real estate market has something for everyone. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer or looking to settle down in a peaceful community, you’ll find properties that suit your lifestyle and budget.

Explore the opportunities that await you in Palmyra, where you can enjoy the perfect blend of small-town charm and contemporary living. Discover your dream home in this delightful village today!

Newest Palmyra Homes for Sale

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1709727 MLS

Welcome to this charming old-style home in Palmyra, offering 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and the perfect blend of character and modern updates! The property also features a versatile bonus room that could be used as a home office, 5th bedroom, craft room, playroom, or whatever best fits your needs. The home has seen numerous upgrades in recent years, including new appliances in 2022, new gutters in 2023, new basement and exterior outlets in 2023, new windows in the primary suite in 2024, a new roof in 2024, and a new water heater in 2024. Comfort and efficiency were further enhanced with the installation of 7 mini-splits in 2025, along with insulation added to the rim joists and attic floor. A new fence was also installed in 2025. Enjoy the added convenience of having a public park directly behind the property, along with a truly unique location just seconds away from the famous Four Corners in Palmyra. This character-filled home offers the charm of an older home with the peace of mind that comes from so many major updates already completed!

138 Church Street, Palmyra

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1708320 MLS

Imagine what you could create on 21.5 acres! This beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 2-bath Colonial offers 2,160 sq ft of living space as well as established trails and newly cleared upper meadow. The northern end of the property's woods has scenic views of neighboring farmland and rolling hills to the east. In the meadow, picture a future pole barn, gardens, horses, a soccer field for the kids, evenings around the stone fire pit, or simply miles of your own trails to hike, hunt and explore by ATV. — Inside, new natural look "Oak" wide-plank LVP flooring, quartz countertops, stainless kitchen appliances, first-floor laundry, first floor primary bedroom w/walk-in closet, bay window and wraparound deck. Many recent improvements including new roof, high-efficiency furnace & hot water tank, updated electrical, new Bilco basement door, new gutters—Located just northeast & close to the Historic Village & even closer to the Erie Canal! Bring your ideas and make this rare, 20+ acre piece of property your own! Delayed Negotiations on file. Offers due Sunday 8/30 @ 7pm

3545 North Creek Road, Palmyra

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1708149 MLS

This beautifully updated 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath home offers a cozy living room with a gas fireplace with new carpeting throughout. Major improvements include a new metal roof and water heater in 2024, a new driveway in 2023, a remodeled bathroom in 2020, and upgraded 200-amp electrical service. All appliances included! The impressive two-story 20' x 60' heated and insulated pole barn is made for work and play, featuring a pellet stove, electric fireplace and flat screen tv, 24-foot wet bar, half bath, and a 12' x 12' garage door. The pole barn's second floor provides an ideal lounge area or abundant storage space. Enjoy a fully fenced backyard with a Trex deck and pergola perfect for relaxing and entertaining!

324 Vienna Street, Palmyra

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1706962 MLS

Welcome to 144 West Charlotte Avenue! This gorgeous, fully renovated ranch offers easy one-floor living in the heart of Palmyra. Featuring 3 bedrooms, 1 beautifully updated bathroom, and convenient first-floor laundry, this home is truly move-in ready. Enjoy a bright, inviting interior with stylish finishes, an updated eat-in kitchen, and included appliances. Multi-zone mini-splits provide year-round comfort. Situated on a spacious lot close to village shops, restaurants, schools, and local amenities. Nothing left to do but unpack and enjoy!

144 W Charlotte Avenue, Palmyra

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1706105 MLS

Come take a look at 2106 Harris Road, Palmyra. This is a 3 + bedroom, 2-bath home in the country with a detached two-car garage and plenty of space for a garden or outdoor hobbies. Newark school district. This property offers peaceful rural living with lots of potential. The home is being sold “As Is” as part of an estate sale. A great opportunity for investors, renovators, or buyers looking to make it their own.

2106 Harris Road, Palmyra

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1705217 MLS

WELCOME HOME to this charming Village property offering 3–4 bedrooms and 1.5 baths! Move-in ready and filled with character, this home features a wonderfully spacious and flexible layout with new laminate flooring throughout. The updated kitchen includes a new dishwasher and refrigerator, plus a walk-in pantry offering plenty of additional storage. Enjoy the convenience of first-floor laundry and relax on either of the TWO inviting porches—perfect for morning coffee or unwinding at the end of the day! Major updates since 2016 include a complete tear-off roof, replacement windows, high-efficiency furnace, 100-amp electrical service, water heater, and kitchen improvements. A wonderful opportunity with so much already done for you. QUICK CLOSING AVAILABLE!

121 Fayette Street, Palmyra

Start Your Search

Eric Geoca

Growing up in a real estate family, I developed a love for real estate from a young age. Geoca Homes Realty was started, by my parents, in 1977. I first earned my real estate license at the age of 18. I received my degree in Electrical Engineering from Bucknell University and received a Master’s degree from Pace University in Business Administration with a specialty in Finance. While working in the corporate world for 17 years, I was awarded several patents relating to the fields of navigation, guidance and control as well as connection technologies. I returned to full time real estate in 2007, when I started building homes. In 2010, I earned my broker’s license and have been the managing broker for Geoca Homes Realty for the last 16 years. As a home builder who worked in the trades during college, I have a true understanding of homes and how they are constructed. I have built over 100 custom homes, as well as rehabbed historic homes. During our 49-year history, we have successfully served clients throughout the Rochester area and the Finger Lakes Region.

Learn More

Tara Morgan

With the heart of an educator and the drive of an entrepreneur, Tara Morgan entered the real estate profession subsequent to her many years as a high school English teacher and as an adjunct professor of writing/research methodologies. As a dedicated teacher, she brought literature and writing to life—often using nature and out-of-classroom settings as springboards for authentic learning. Shortly after the start of her real estate career, Tara became a multi-million-dollar producer and a recipient of several sales and client-service awards. Known for her professionalism, positive attitude, and strong work ethic, Tara rapidly built a thriving business with her client-centered approach. She is steadfast in her belief that agents must add real value to any real estate transaction in which they are involved, using knowledge, integrity, compassion, and patience. She is a proud mother of two incredible young ladies. Architecture, photography, and history are some of her favorite diversions. Tara holds a Master of Science in Childhood Education and a Bachelor of Arts in Journalism/Communications. She is a New York State Licensed Real Estate Salesperson and an SRES (Seniors Real Estate Specialist-NAR Designation).

Learn More

Jeff Griggs

As a real estate agent with Geoca Homes, Jeff Griggs believes clients should feel informed, supported, and never rushed when purchasing or selling a home. After a career as a firefighter, Jeff brings a calm, steady approach built on trust, communication, and service. Family is at the center of everything Jeff does and he understands how important a home is to building stability and lasting memories. He takes pride in guiding his clients every step of the way, with care and attention to detail.

Learn More

Lynne Tempest

Lynne Tempest grew up in a family-owned real estate and home building business, seeing firsthand what goes into helping people buy, sell, and build homes. She began her career at an advertising agency in Rochester, NY, before moving to New Jersey to work for the nation’s largest consumer wireless carrier where she launched Verizon’s "Can you hear me now?" campaign, successfully shifting consumer focus from price to premium service. She was responsible for go-to-market strategy, project management, and cross-functional leadership to build advertising, events, and social media content that delivered measurable results. Lynne's professional experience honed exceptional marketing, organization, negotiation, and problem-solving skills that she now applies to assist clients with their real estate goals.

Learn More