Arcadia Homes for Sale

Arcadia Homes for Sale

Welcome to Arcadia, New York, a charming town nestled in the heart of Wayne County. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Arcadia offers a delightful blend of rural tranquility and modern conveniences. With its rich agricultural heritage and stunning views of the surrounding countryside, this area is perfect for those seeking a peaceful lifestyle while remaining connected to nearby urban amenities.

Arcadia boasts a variety of recreational opportunities, from scenic parks to local farms, ensuring residents can enjoy the great outdoors year-round. The town is also home to a vibrant community spirit, with numerous events and gatherings that celebrate the unique character of this region. Whether you’re strolling through the local farmers' market or enjoying a summer festival, you’ll quickly find that Arcadia is a place where neighbors become friends.

For those considering a move, Arcadia features a diverse selection of homes for sale that cater to various lifestyles and budgets. From charming single-family homes with sprawling yards to modern townhouses with contemporary finishes, there is something for everyone in this inviting community. Many properties are surrounded by lush greenery, offering a serene retreat after a long day.

With its strong sense of community, beautiful scenery, and attractive real estate options, Arcadia is an ideal location for families, retirees, and anyone looking to embrace a relaxed lifestyle. Come explore the homes for sale in Arcadia and discover your perfect piece of this idyllic New York town!

Newest Arcadia Homes for Sale

$159,900
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1709976 MLS
Welcome home to this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath, two-story home located in the Village of Newark! Step inside to find an updated kitchen and bathroom, along with comfortable living spaces ready to make your own. Outside, you'll love the large, partially fenced backyard, offering plenty of room for pets, entertaining, gardening, or simply relaxing. A gazebo provides the perfect spot for summer evenings and outdoor gatherings. One of the standout features of this property is the large garage, with approximately half of the space converted into additional living space, offering tons of possibilities for a recreation room, home office, hobby space, or bonus area while still maintaining garage/storage space. Conveniently located in the Village of Newark, close to shopping, restaurants, schools, parks, and village amenities. With its updated interior, spacious yard, bonus living space, and versatile garage, this home has plenty to offer!

217 E Miller St, Arcadia
$129,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1710260 MLS
Welcome home to this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath two-story home nestled on a quiet street in the Village of Newark. A welcoming covered front porch offers the perfect spot to relax and enjoy the neighborhood. Inside, you'll find a comfortable and functional layout with plenty of potential to make the space your own. With three bedrooms, two levels of living space, and a convenient village location close to shopping, restaurants, schools, parks, and other local amenities, this home is a great opportunity for a first-time buyer, downsizer, or anyone looking for an affordable place to call home. Come see all the possibilities this Newark home has to offer! Comes with parcel across street as well. Additional .15 acres. Driveway is on this additional parcel. Delayed negotiations until Wednesday September 2nd at 3pm.

316 E Myrtle Ave, Arcadia
$99,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1710181 MLS
Here is your chance to bring this long-established property back to life. Built in 1850, this 2,342 square-foot farmhouse sits on 1.8 acres in the town of Arcadia, just outside the Town of Lyons. A short drive to Route 31, the Erie Canal, and Route 14, with Geneva, Newark, and Rochester all within easy reach. The home features 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms across two stories, boasting a classic farmhouse layout. This layout includes a first-floor primary suite, an eat-in country kitchen, a first-floor laundry, and a morning room off the main living space! Covered and enclosed porches wrap the exterior, the kind of touches that are hard to find in new construction. The lot offers plenty of space to roam, inside and out, with room to garden, park equipment, or simply enjoy the privacy that comes with acreage this close to town! This is a great property if you are looking to truly make something your own with each project and restore that big farmhouse you always dreamed of! The bones, layout, and character are here, offering a strong foundation to build from. A thoughtful renovation here carries genuine long-term upside, whether your plan is to restore it as a forever home, hold it as a rental, or reposition it for resale down the road. The property will be sold as-is: a blank canvas in a location close enough to everyday convenience, yet quiet enough to feel like your own piece of the country. Just waiting for the right person to bring their vision to life! Showings begin, Tuesday, August 27th @9am and Offers are due Wednesday, September 2nd @12pm.

3263 Lembke Road, Arcadia
$186,500
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1706443 MLS
WELCOME TO THIS CHARMING CAPE COD, NESTLED IN A HIGHLY DESIRABLE, WALKABLE NEIGHBORHOOD WHERE SCHOOLS, LOCAL SHOPS AND COMMUNITY AMENITIES ARE JUST STEPS FROM YOUR FRONT DOOR! CHARACTER AND WARMTH GREET YOU THE MOMENT YOU STEP INSIDE THIS CLASSIC COZY HOME. THE INVITING FLOOR PLAN CONNECTS THE COMFORTABLE LIVING AND DINING AREAS WITH A NICELY UPDATED KITCHEN, CREATING AN EASY FLOW FOR EVERYDAY LIVING AND ENTERTAINING. RELAX AND UNWIND IN THE SPACIOUS SUNROOM AT THE REAR OF THE HOME, OR STEP OUTSIDE TO THE DECK AND DISCOVER A SURPRISINGLY DEEP BACKYARD FILLED WITH POSSIBILITIES. MATURE TREES PROVIDE A LOVELY BACKDROP, WHILE THE EXPANSIVE YARD OFFERS THE PERFECT CANVAS FOR CREATING YOUR OWN ENGLISH GARDEN, OUTDOOR ENTERTAINING SPACE OR BACKYARD RETREAT. UPSTAIRS YOU’LL FIND THREE COZY BEDROOMS FEATURING BEAUTIFUL HARDWOOD FLOORS, ALONG WITH AN UPDATED FULL BATH WITH WALK-IN SHOWER. ROUNDING OUT THIS CHARMING PROPERTY IS A PARTIALLY FINISHED BASEMENT, AN EXTENDED GARAGE OFFERING ADDITIONAL STORAGE AND A GREAT DEDICATED WORKSPACE FOR HOBBIES, PROJECTS OR ALL THOSE EXTRAS. A WONDERFUL OPPORTUNITY TO ENJOY THE CHARACTER OF A CLASSIC CHARMING CAPE COD, A CONVENIENT WALKABLE LOCATION AND A DEEP BACKYARD JUST WAITING FOR YOUR PERSONAL TOUCH! Delayed Negotiations until Tues., Sept.1, at 7:00 pm

112 Peirson Avenue, Arcadia
$149,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1708591 MLS
Welcome to this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath Cape Cod located in the heart of the Village of Newark! Situated on a desirable corner lot, this adorable home offers plenty of curb appeal and a warm, welcoming feel from the moment you arrive. Inside, you'll find a comfortable and functional layout with plenty of potential to make it your own. A one-car detached garage provides convenient parking and additional storage. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer, looking to downsize, or searching for an affordable home in the village, this property is a great opportunity. Sold as is. Seller will not make any repairs called out by lenders. Seller reserves the right to leave any unwanted personal items behind. Delayed negotiations until Tuesday September 1st at 3pm.

235 Peirson Ave, Arcadia
$189,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1709136 MLS
This 1894 Victorian is waiting for you to move in and enjoy all the original charm that has been maintained and all the renovations and updates that have been done since 2015. It is truly Move-in Ready! Be sure to look through the pictures with added remarks to see the patterned hardwood floors and natural trim and the decorative Art Deco style fireplace with electric insert. The 2015-2016 renovations added some modern features including a large eat-in Kitchen with a movable island and stainless-steel appliances, a Primary Suite with a walk-in closet and bathroom, 2 1/2 bathrooms including a 1st floor powder room,1st floor laundry area, central air conditioning and a 55 gallon water heater. Those renovations also included a new roof and windows, interior and exterior painting, new gas furnace, plumbing and electrical wiring. A 3 Season Room (12'x15' approx) was added to the back of the house in 2020. 4 ceiling fans were added in the Living Room, Dining Room, Primary Bedroom, and 3 Season Room. 2 Crank-down Sunshades were installed on the front porch at the front/East side and the South side to extend your enjoyment time. Blown-in insulation was added to the attic which limits access to the attic. Recent work this year includes exterior painted in June, new upgraded electrical box and exterior wiring in July, regraveled driveway in July, and landscape work with new shrubs added. The backyard is treed and 'back to nature' at the rear with a good size shed (2000) for storage. The 66' X 242' (.36 acre) lot size gives you a deep backyard for recreation, gardening, and/or to build a garage. Delayed Negotiations until Monday August 31 at 2pm.

519 East Avenue, Arcadia
$198,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1705912 MLS
Charming & Well-Maintained Cape Cod With Beautiful Backyard Oasis. Welcome To This Well-Maintained Cape Cod, Conveniently Located Within Walking Distance To Newark Schools. This Inviting Home Offers Two Upstairs Bedrooms, One Full Bath, A One-Car Attached Garage, And Additional Finished Lower-Level Space That Provides Flexibility For A Potential Third Bedroom, Home Office, Recreation Room, Or Guest Space. The Updated Kitchen Features Beautiful Quartz Countertops, A Convenient Breakfast/Coffee Bar, And An Adjoining Dining Room, Creating A Warm And Functional Space For Everyday Living And Entertaining. Additional Improvements Include An Updated Bathroom With A New Vanity, Toilet, Flooring, Light Fixtures, And Medicine Cabinet, Along With Fresh Neutral Paint And Attractive Flooring Throughout The Home. Step Outside And Discover One Of The True Highlights Of This Property: A Private, Fully Fenced Backyard Oasis Designed For Enjoying The Best Of Summer. The Spacious Yard Features Attractive Hardscaping, A Newer Deck, And A Pool, Creating Multiple Areas For Relaxing And Entertaining. Whether You're Enjoying Your Morning Coffee, Hosting Summer Gatherings, Or Unwinding By The Pool, This Backyard Offers A Wonderful Setting For Outdoor Living. The Fenced Yard Also Provides Plenty Of Room For Outdoor Activities And Pets, While The Storage Shed Offers Convenient Space For Lawn Equipment, Outdoor Supplies, And Seasonal Items. Additional Updates Include New Windows And Gutters In 2025, A New Electrical Panel In 2023, Pool And Deck In 2023, A New Metal Exterior Door In 2023, And A Hot Water Tank Replaced In 2018. Don't Miss The Opportunity To Enjoy A Home That Combines Character, Thoughtful Updates, Functional Living Space, And An Inviting Outdoor Lifestyle, All In A Convenient Newark Location. Delayed Negotiations With Offers Due 8/29/2026 At 10 AM

730 Peirson Avenue, Arcadia
$19,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1708195 MLS
Uncover the hidden charm in this Colonial gem located in the heart of Newark! This four-bedroom, one and a half bath treasure offers an incredible opportunity for those with a discerning eye and a passion for renovation. While it currently requires a thorough rehab, it's perfect for somone looking for your next project to flip or for investment. This home has so much potential for someone. Front open porch. Rear 2-tier deck overlooks fenced in yard. Partially finished room in the full basement. Convenient Village location with close-by amenties. 1-car detached garage. Group showing saturday 8/22/26 from 12:00-12:30. Holdharm form will be required to sign for entry. GROUP SHOWING HAS BEEN CANCELED

118 Wilson Street, Arcadia
$169,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1701008 MLS
Price Adjustment!! Welcome to this 4 bedroom and 2 full baths home sitting on .83 acres. This charming home has an enclosed porch with a new mudroom that leads you right into the living room. Hardwoods line this house through out. With a new kitchen recently installed and downstairs bathroom for easy access. Upstairs you will find 4 bedrooms with a bathroom upstairs as well. This home is ready to live in or ready for restoration or even adding your own touch to it. This home is just 5 minutes away from the village. With easy access to shopping, the Erie Canal and walking trails this house is a perfect location to enjoy country living. With wooded area behind the house providing some extra seclusion. With a 1 car garage by the driveway. With mature trees providing plenty of shade for adding a patio or gazebo the options are endless for this house.

6021 Whitings Corners Road, Arcadia
$119,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1702339 MLS
Here’s your opportunity to move to an AFFORDABLE home in the country! Just under half an acre WITH AN ADDITIONAL 3+ ACRES AVAILABLE RIGHT NEXT DOOR! This 1875 home with a 1961 detached TWO + CAR GARAGE /WORKSHOP is ready for YOU to complete it! Imagine the peaceful afternoons spent on the COVERED FRONT PORCH or the REAR DECK - cook out or just relax and watch the DEER and TURKEY stroll through your yard! INSIDE you’ll enjoy a LARGE LIVING ROOM- a FIRST FLOOR LAUNDRY ROOM (with lots of storage!) a dining area that opens to the kitchen and another entryway that can be used ANYWAY YOU CHOOSE! Upstairs there’s a FULL BATH and two bedrooms! There’s plenty of outdoor PRIVATE space too! Property can be purchased as a package with additional parcel R1703195 - Tax ID: 542001-068-111-0016-898-339-0000. Delayed Negotiations - Offers due 08/24 @ Noon

369 Bloom Road, Arcadia
$60,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1705049 MLS
Opportunity awaits! Located in a peaceful country setting, this property offers the chance to renovate and make it your own. The home is ready for updates and improvements and offers a functional layout with plenty of potential. Enjoy the privacy of a rural setting while remaining just minutes from Newark and local amenities. Property is being sold as-is.

6611 Old Lyons Road, Arcadia
$109,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1705184 MLS
Welcome to this charming Erie Canal waterfront home offering peaceful views and endless potential! This 1 bed, 1 bath home features 1,218 sq ft of living space, central air, updated PVC plumbing, a solid pier and beam foundation, and convenient driveway parking. Step outside to your private dock with direct access to the Erie Canal—perfect for boating, fishing, or simply enjoying the waterfront lifestyle. Whether you're looking for a cozy full-time residence, weekend retreat, or investment opportunity, this unique canal-front property is one you won't want to miss!

Arcadia
Start Your Search